Dr. Scholl’s Women’s Madison Sneaker


Product ASIN : B0BJGSQ5X8
Rating : 4
Price : $80.00 - $58.56
(as of Oct 28, 2025 09:04:50 UTC – Details)

Customers say

Customers find these sneakers comfortable, cute, and great for everyday wear, with good arch support. However, the fit receives mixed feedback – while some say they run small and narrow, others find them too big. Moreover, durability is a concern as some report the right shoe coming apart and the sole separating. Additionally, customers report issues with blisters on ankles and rubbing at the back of the shoe.

Top reviews
Reviewer: Ruth
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Perfect pair
Review: True to size but seems slightly narrow. Haven’t worn out yet but hope it stretches slightly. Comfortable. Classy. Great price. Sturdy. Exactly what I was looking for. Happy with the purchase.

Reviewer: imblessedx6
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Great pair of shoes!
Review: Fantastic pair of slip on tennis shoes. True to size and very comfortable!

Reviewer: Krista Gigliotti
Rating: 4.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Love the shoe but fit varies by color
Review: This would be 5 stars if it weren’t for my experience with my 2nd purchase. I originally purchased the gray cloud microfiber version of this shoe and loved them. ImThey are so comfortable, had great arch support, and I wore them everywhere. I was obsessed with the style and comfort. After 2 years I decided to buy a new pair because mine was getting worn out. Purchased the oyster microfiber to switch up the color. This color fit completely different. They were not comfortable, the support wasn’t there, and the size was off (even though I got the same size as my first pair). After wearing them for a few hours I decided a return was in order. It wasn’t what I was expecting and my worn out shoes I’d been wearing for 2 years were 10x more comfortable.Returned the oyster microfiber option and went back to the tried and true – gray cloud microfiber. Happy to report that the gray matched my high expectations. They match the comfort of my original shoe! I have no clue why 2 different colors of what is supposedly the same shoe would feel so different. But I have both colors right now because I haven’t returned the oyster color yet and when I put one shoe on each foot they feel like 2 completely different shoes.A long way of saying “get the gray cloud microfiber and you’ll be super happy!”

Reviewer: Kindle Customer
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Nice cushion for standing at work all day
Review: I used to wear these shoes to work almost every day. I stand a majority of the day at my job so I can confidently say they were a comfortable shoe choice and that they lasted pretty well. It can be a little hard to keep the suede clean but other than that I would purchase these again!

Reviewer: B.C.
Rating: 3.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Cute and comfy but need to size down
Review: Ordered size 8 based on brand sizing and reviews. I’m typically a 7/7.5-8 and slightly wide. Size 8 fits ok in toe box but is loose in heel area. My feet slips out when I walk and I will need to add heel protectors to prevent blisters.

Reviewer: Jessica B.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Great for long walks when the weather may be a little wet.
Review: These are great. I took them on a cruise to Southeast Asia and they were a great alternative to canvas sneakers when it was wet outside. Easy to slip on and worked well for casual or business casual. Wore with wide-leg pants and skirts. Comfortable enough for all-day walking.

Reviewer: NancyD
Rating: 1.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Cannot recommend
Review: I have purchased several of these Dr. Scholl’s shoes before but this was my first time buying from this seller. I originally posted a negative review regarding the back of one of the shoes digging into the back of my foot. But I took it down after wearing the shoes several times and they loosened up some, although they were still digging a bit. I wore a bandaid on the back of my foot for probably the first 3 weeks or so, just to enable me to wear them. So I’ve had them several weeks now and the other day, it was pouring down rain when I took my dog out. I was walking through wet grass as well as puddles. These shoes did not keep my feet dry. It’s happened more than once with this particular pair of shoes. I’ve never had this happen with a pair of these Dr. Scholl’s shoes. (When I removed the insole of this shoe, it looks like they are cheaply stitched together around the sole of the shoe.) This is the big reason I buy this Dr. Scholl’s shoe, so I can walk my dog in inclement weather and keep my feet dry. So, I have purchased from my other seller and unfortunately, this pair is going in the trash. I cannot recommend this shoe from this seller.

Reviewer: Jade Milbrandt
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Exchanged for a half size down – perfect fit after that!
Review: I do not have any other shoes with flat bottoms like this. I have high arches that ache badly if unsupported. I can’t wear flats at all because of them. I’ve never been able to wear this style of shoe before. I most often fit a size 8 or 7.5 depending on shoe style and manufacturer. After a lot of researching I heard great things about these so I ordered my typical size (8) when they were on sale. The size 8 were surprisingly too loose and too wide. I exchanged them for a half size down.The 7.5 size fits perfect! At first I wasn’t used to the style and shape of the toe box but it wasn’t uncomfortable or painful – I’m just used to sneakers with larger toe boxes. My toes adjusted pretty quickly after several wears. I love these shoes! The support is better than I could’ve imagined! I work as an elementary educator with concrete/hard tile floors and am on my feet nearly all day long. These shoes give my all the support my arches and back need. Plus they are more professional looking than my nice tennis shoes. I can dress them up or down with ease and this black style looks cute (for me) with low, ankle, or longer socks.I’ve been looking for shoes like this for years and just figured I’d never be able to find a pair that worked for me. Not the case anymore! I’ve been wearing them almost daily for nearly 4 months now. These have become my daily shoes instead of my nice sneakers. They haven’t torn on the sides or bottom, there’s been no weird stretching out, no scratches on the top or sides (and I’m rough on shoes), no blisters or rubbing at all and the support has stayed! I love the padding on the heel and ankle of this shoe. My feet don’t feel sore after taking these off even after a long day. Even during some 12+ hour days of teaching followed by errands and church in the evenings afterward, the support is there and keeps me on my feet.So far I’ve been able to wear these all week long teaching and during the weekend without the comfort or support fading. I’m asking for another pair in a different color for Christmas! Hoping a different color/fabric will still feel and hold up the same way.If you’ve struggled to find this style of shoe due to high arches or other support/comfort problems- these might be worth a try for you. I recommend purchasing when on sale if it’s hard for you to pull the spending trigger on shoes more than $25 or so (like it is for me). For how popular these shoes are, $50.00 seems like a fantastic deal! Here’s to happy, healthy, supported feet 👣.

Reviewer: Sara Stella
Rating: 2.0 out of 5 stars
Title:
Review: Ho ordinato un 37eu e mi son ritrovata un 36.5 che ovviamente è risultato stretto! Quindi non posso neppure pronunciarmi su comodità o altro xchè stringono da morire. Farò il reso xó che barba, già ho dovuto aspettare 5gg per averle.

Reviewer: jacob mohino balet
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title:
Review: Creo que son los zaptos mas comodos que he tenido nunca!

Reviewer: Pedro
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title:
Review: Talla ligeramente grande

Reviewer: Lidia R.
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title:
Review: Calzo del 11w y estos me quedaron perfectos, siempre batallo por el ancho pero estos estan a mi medida para nada apretados, estan super para el diario

Reviewer: genoveva maldonado lara
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title:
Review: Los uso porque son cómodos y bonitos